Loss of use. Being without your vehicle has a value.
Texas law recognizes damages for the loss of use of a vehicle. It does not require that you rented one.
Gavit Law handles loss-of-use disputes for Texas vehicle owners, including claims where the insurer stops counting at 28 or 30 days.
Discuss Your ClaimThe rule
Two Texas Supreme Court decisions frame the claim.
- Luna v. North Star Dodge Sales, Inc.
667 S.W.2d 115 (Tex. 1984) - The Court held that a claimant does not necessarily have to rent a replacement automobile, or actually spend money on substitute transportation, to prove loss of use. The reasonable rental value of a comparable substitute can be evidence of the loss.
- J&D Towing, LLC v. American Alternative Insurance Corp.
478 S.W.3d 649 (Tex. 2016) - The Court held that an owner of totally destroyed personal property may recover loss-of-use damages in addition to the property’s pre-loss fair market value, but not for longer than the period reasonably needed to replace the property.
The 30-day question
An insurer’s rental guideline is not the law.
There is no single Texas tort rule that automatically limits every third-party loss-of-use claim to 28 or 30 days. The focus is the reasonable value and reasonable duration of the lost use, together with causation and mitigation.
Repairable vehicle
The reasonable repair period
Relevant facts can include supplements, parts delays, shop scheduling, insurer inspections or approvals, and whether the owner acted reasonably to move the repair forward.
A long repair period does not automatically make the entire period compensable. But the passage of 30 days does not automatically end the claim either.
Total loss
The time reasonably needed to replace it
For a total loss, the focus is the period reasonably necessary to obtain a replacement.
If the owner kept incurring losses after a reasonable replacement could have been obtained, the recoverable period may be reduced.
How it is measured
A comparable substitute, at a reasonable rate.
- Rental value
- For a personal vehicle, reasonable substitute rental value is often the cleanest measure. Evidence may include comparable rental rates by the day, week, or month.
- A comparable vehicle
- The substitute should be reasonable in light of the character and use of the damaged vehicle. A work pickup, passenger van, or specialized commercial vehicle may have a different reasonable substitute value than an economy compact.
- Not extravagant
- That does not mean the claimant is entitled to an extravagant rental. The rate still has to be reasonable and supported.
- Business use
- In an appropriate business-use case, other provable economic loss, such as lost profits, may be relevant. Those damages require their own proof.
Two different claims
Rental coverage is a contract. Loss of use is a damage.
First-party
Your own rental reimbursement
Your own policy may cap rental reimbursement by day, by duration, or by total amount. That is a contractual coverage question.
Third-party
A claim against the at-fault driver
The issue is the legally provable loss caused by the collision, subject to reasonableness, mitigation, and available coverage. Policy limits in your own rental coverage are different from the damages an at-fault driver may owe.
Keep a clean timeline
- Comparable rental quotes
- Actual rental invoices, if any
- Repair-shop intake and completion dates
- Supplements and approval dates
- Parts-delay records
- Insurer emails and call notes
- Total-loss communications
- Replacement-shopping records
- Business records, in an appropriate commercial claim
Common questions
Loss of use, answered directly.
What if repairs take 60, 90, or 100 days?
If the owner promptly placed the vehicle in a qualified shop and the delay resulted from necessary supplements, parts availability, insurer approval, or other reasonable repair issues, those facts may support a longer period.
If the owner caused avoidable delay, the recoverable period may be reduced.
Do I have to rent a car to have a claim?
Not necessarily. In Luna, the Texas Supreme Court held that a claimant does not necessarily have to rent a replacement automobile to prove loss of use. Actual rental invoices can be useful evidence, but an actual rental is not always required. The amount and duration still must be reasonable and supported by evidence.
Can I recover loss of use if my vehicle was totaled?
Potentially, yes. Under J&D Towing, loss-of-use damages can be available when personal property is totally destroyed, for the period reasonably needed to replace it.
Does the substitute have to be the cheapest vehicle available?
Not necessarily. The claimed substitute should be reasonable in light of the character and use of the damaged vehicle.
Related reading
